## 2010/01/02

### ۂƂCeWFgfUCEgnor

׋ۂ̕ږт⌌tÌŌnȂǁuҌs\ɕGvƎ咣̂̕i݁AނƗނ̒ԌԂiKɌĂŁAn_҂̖hqCƂĂ̂Au]ESEvłB

ƂƂŁACeWFgfUC̖{RDiscovery InstitutěuOMŵЂMichael Egnoȓ݂咣F
"confusing the question of how the brain causes mind with the question of does the brain cause mind"

uɔ]S邩ƁA]S邩ۂAႦ邱Ɓv

Dr. Novella elides the central problem with strict materialism in the mind-brain problem. The first question isnft "how the brain causes the mind" or "does the brain cause the mind." The primary question is this:

Dr. NovelláASƔ]̖́AiȗB_̒SI𖳎ĂBŏ̖́AuɁA]͐S邩vł͂ȂB邢́Au]͐SĂ邩vłȂBŏ̖͂łB

can the brain cause the mind?

u]͐S邩Hv

In order to subject a theory to empirical test, it must first be logically coherent. Materialism fails as logic. What does it mean to say, "The brain causes subjective experience"? There is nothing about the physical scientific description of the brain that invokes subjectivity. The salient qualities of the mind — free will, restricted access and incorrigibility, qualia, intentionality, persistence of self over time, and unity of consciousness — are not properties of matter. Subjectivity is imputed by materialists to neural function, without coherent explanation or logical law-like dependence. The materialist assertion that the brain is the entire cause of the mind is merely an act of faith appended to the science.

_oIɌ؂ɂ́A܂A_Iɂɋ؂ʂĂȂ΂ȂȂBB_͘_ƂĎsĂBu]͎ϓIȌo邩vƂ͉Ӗ̂H@ς܂ޔ]ɂĂ̕IȊwIȋLq͂ȂBŠȓł鎩RӎuEꂽANZX[̎vlo]Eł[_js\ȒmEԂFƂ]ENIA[ϓIo]EӐ}[̊Oɂ̂Ɍy\́EӖt]EȂ̎[]\镨ւĂl]Eӎ͕̓̑ł͂ȂBς́Aт܂͘_I@ˑȂɁAB_҂ɂĐ_o@\ɂ̂ƂB]ŜׂĂłƂB_If́AȊwɕtM̐킴ɂȂB

[Michael Egnor:"Itfs Time for Me to Unshatter My Three Pillars of Neuroscience Denial..." (2009/01/08) on Discovery InstituteuO]
_̌"God of the gaps"ƓŁAuȊwIɐȂv_ƂĂB

A"""zIȐ_"قǂ͊ȒPȂBƂ̂...

• ꎩ̂́AȒ݂ŁAȊwIɌołȂƂdlł܂Ȃ
• REϑ@́AlԂ̐_onoRĂAڂɊOEϑĂ悭AȊwIɌoȂƂdlł܂Ȃ
• A]ɊȂAvƂAlԂ͕̓̂\łȂB
• ɂ]ւ̊́AȊwIɌołȂƂdlł܂Ȃ
• AOƊŔ]̏Ԃ͈ĂȂ΂ȂȂB͉ȊwIɌołȂ΂ȂȂB]vĂȂǁAvƂ𕶎ɏ߂ɂ́A]ɂ"v"炩̌`ŎcȂƂȂB]̂̂ϑĂāARE̊O̊""ȂȂA͔]ɍpĂȂƂɂȂB
ŁAołȂȂ...
• ݂̋Zpł͌os\
• 邢́A݂͑邩ȂA]ɂ͊ĂȂ
̂ꂩB

CeWFgfUCx҂͂Aű݂Zpł͌os\vƌĂ̂yȂ̂ŁA{CōɍsƂ͂Ȃ낤BɒTɍsāAȂƁAȂuRg[肵߂FPSvCĂ肪ARg[̓Q[}Vɂ͂ȂĂȂvɋ߂ÂĂƂɂȂB͂Ɋ}Ȃ󋵁B

^OFDI id_
yDiscoveryInstitute̍ŐVLz
posted by Kumicit at 2010/01/02 00:00 | Comment(0) | TrackBack(0) | DiscoveryInstitute | |
̋Lւ̃Rg
Rg
O:

[AhX:

z[y[WAhX:

Rg: [K{]

̋Lւ̃gbNobN